X-Ray Spectrometry of Cartridge Brass

X-Ray Spectrometers Reveal Metal Content of Major Cartridge Brass Brands

X-Ray cartridge Brass testingAre there significant metallurgical differences in the alloys used in various brands of cartridge brass? The answer is yes, and we have proof. Using a state-of-the-art X-Ray Fluorescence Spectrometer, some tech-savy Wisconsin shooters recently analyzed the alloys in seven different types of cartridge brass.

The test results revealed significant differences in the percentages of copper and zinc in the different brands. Copper content ranged from a low of 72% by mass (Winchester, S&B) to a high of 80% by mass (Remington). Zinc, which adds hardness to the alloy, ranged from a low of 20% by mass (Federal) to a high of 36% (‘brown box’ Lapua). Interestingly, the tests, as reported by Forum Member Fred Bohl, revealed that the alloy in the new ‘blue box’ 6mmBR Lapua brass is different than the alloy in Lapua’s older ‘brown box’ 6mmBR brass. Specifically, the ‘blue box’ 6mmBR brass has more copper and less tin (by mass). Here’s a summary of the X-Ray Fluorescence spectrometry tests:

X-Ray cartridge Brass testing

This testing was done at major science laboratory, using high-grade X-Ray Spectrometry Analyzing equipment. Fred reports that: “The data was run by one of the club members with the permission of the test lab supervisor who is also a club member and shooter. The data in original output reports was far more detailed about trace elements at lower orders of magnitude primarily from surface contaminants (some were rerun after establishing a repeatable cleaning procedure)”. The testing process is discussed in this Shooters’ Forum thread.

We do NOT have the metallurgical expertise to infer that any particular alloy shown above is “better” than another. The alloy “blend” is merely one of many variables that can have an impact on the performance and quality of the finished product. Annealing times/methods differ and some cartridge brass is extruded while other cartridge brass is made with the traditional drawing process. Readers should not presume, on reading the above chart, that they can identify the “best shooting” brass simply based on the constituent metals in the various alloys.

X-Ray cartridge Brass testing

General Observations about Cartridge Brass Alloys
With the cartridge brass X-Ray Spectrometry results in hand, Fred Bohl hoped to find out what “real world” conclusions (if any) we could draw from the raw data. Fred sent the test results to some knowledgeable metallurgists, soliciting their comments. Fred explains: “When I first posted this information [in the Shooters’ Forum], I had hoped to elicit replies from expert metallurgists and to initiate a useful discussion. From [their replies] I distilled the following ‘consensus’ comments”:

1. The range of Copper/Zinc ratios suitable for use in cartridge making by typical processes is 85/15 to 65/35 (% by weight or mass).

2. The range of Copper/Zinc ratios suitable for use in cartridges intended for reloading is 80/20 to 70/30. Above 80% copper, the resulting case would tend to be too soft and difficult to attain the distribution of hardness desired (harder at the base and softer at the neck). Below 70% copper the resulting case would tend to be too hard, would work harden too quickly and require frequent annealing. [Editor: That said, the ‘brown box’ 6mmBR Lapua brass, with 62% copper/36% zinc content, enjoys an unrivaled reputation for both accuracy and its ability to perform well after a dozen or more reloading cycles. We know 30BR shooters who have shot the same old-style Lapua brass (6mmBR parent case) more than 50 times. So maybe the “expert” view needs re-thinking.]

3. As the percentage of zinc increases, the tensile strength, yield strength and hardness tend to increase. However, above 35% zinc, while tensile strength will continue to tend to increase, both yield strength and hardness will tend to begin to decrease.

4. The trace additives of iron and/or silicon are used to control the processing characteristics of the alloy. Trace additions of chromium will improve corrosion resistance and give a shinier surface (both largely cosmetic).

5. Selection of the alloy and additives is a trade off among: end use desired properties; processing time and yield; and cost of materials. For example, the classic 70/30 cartridge brass was considered an optimum combination of corrosion resistance and hardness for single use by the military with good process yield at acceptable material cost.

6. All of my responding experts were surprised by the brown box Lapua alloy except for the oldest. He remembered using an almost identical alloy late in WWII when copper was in very short supply for military small arms ammunition.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

700-505 640-911 M70-301 70-489 700-501 M70-101 70-458 70-341 70-464 70-680 74-335 70-687 70-457 n10-005 1z0-061 220-801 70-465 exam C4090-958 MB2-867J MB2-868 MB2-876 MB3-207 MB3-208 MB3-209 MB3-210 MB3-214 MB3-215 MB3-216 MB3-230 P2060-001 P2060-002 P2060-017 P2070-055 P2070-071 P2070-072 VCAW510 VCP-310 VCP-410 VCP-411 VCP-510 VCP-511 VCP-550 1Z1-821 1Z1-822 1Z1-850 1Z1-851 74-353 74-404 74-409 74-674 74-676 70-410 70-460 70-461 70-462 200-120 70-488 MB2-703 70-411 mb5-705 70-346 70-486 70-347 70-480 70-483 70-412 70-463 mb2-700 3X0-203 3X0-204 400-051 400-101 500-005 500-051 500-201 500-254 500-285 510-014 510-015 810-420 820-421 820-422 83-640 850-001 920-093 A2040-986 A2040-988 A2050-219 A2050-723 BR0-002 BR0-003 C_A1FIN_10 C_BOCR_08 CX-310-019 CX-310-027 CX-310-052 CX-310-053 MB2-498 MB2-631 MB2-632 MB2-633 MB2-634 MB2-700 MB2-701 MB2-702 MB2-703 MB2-866 MB2-867 642-054 642-055 642-061 642-062 642-066 642-067 642-071 642-072 642-081 642-091 070-086 070-089 070-121 070-122 070-123 070-158 070-162 070-169 070-177 070-178 070-181 070-210 070-214 E20-016 E20-017 E20-018 E20-040 E20-050 E20-060 HP0-207 HP0-216 HP0-236 HP0-238 HP0-239 HP0-240 HP0-242 JN0-694 JN0-696 JN0-730 L50-501 L50-502 L50-503 LOT-402 LOT-403 LOT-404 windows 7 key windows 7 key windows 7 key windows 7 key Windows-8-Enterprise-Key Windows-8-Enterprise-Key-sale cheap-Windows-8-Key Windows-8-1-Key Windows-8-Standard-Key Windows-8-Standard-Key-online buy-Windows-8-Standard-Key windows-7-key buy-windows-7-key windows-7-key-sale cheap-windows-7-key-for-sale windows-7-key-sale-oem windows-7-key-sale-finmde buy-Windows-8-Key windows-7-key-for-sale cheap-windows-7-key-sale windows-7-ultimate-serial-product 18630-product-key-number windows-7-all-number windows-7-product-keys windows-8-professional-product-keys windows-8-product-keys-serial-keys windows-8-professional-product-key windows-8-product-key Office-2013-Professional-Key Office-2010-Professional-Key windows81-product-key